Hawaii shore excursions: ship vs independent
Carnival excursions in the Hawaii cost +30% compared with independent tours of the same type (typical saving $17 per person); NCL excursions in the Hawaii cost +56% compared with independent tours of the same type (typical saving $80 per person). 1 of 4 ports are tender ports. Prices checked November 2026.
4 Hawaii ports, with each cruise line's excursion markup over independent tours of the same type and how safe it is to go on your own.
| Port | Carnival markup | NCL markup | Avg safety | Tender? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HonoluluUSA | +126% | +81% | 5.0/5 | No |
| Maui (Kahului)USA | +6% | +62% | 4.5/5 | No |
| KonaUSA | +0% | +64% | 3.8/5 | Yes |
| HiloUSA | -12% | +15% | 5.0/5 | No |
Biggest savings in Hawaii
| Port | Line | Tour type | Ship | Independent | Saving for 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maui (Kahului) | NCL | Whale watching | $271 | $94 | $709 |
| Maui (Kahului) | NCL | Catamaran / sail & snorkel | $330 | $182 | $594 |
| Kona | NCL | Snorkel tour | $227 | $115 | $447 |
| Maui (Kahului) | NCL | Beach break / beach club | $276 | $178 | $394 |
| Maui (Kahului) | Carnival | Snorkel tour | $219 | $140 | $314 |
| Maui (Kahului) | NCL | Nature / waterfall / park | $261 | $187 | $295 |
| Honolulu | Carnival | City / island tour | $114 | $69 | $182 |
| Maui (Kahului) | Carnival | Nature / waterfall / park | $225 | $187 | $150 |
| Honolulu | NCL | City / island tour | $89 | $69 | $79 |
| Hilo | NCL | Nature / waterfall / park | $197 | $188 | $39 |
Questions
Are Hawaii cruise excursions worth booking through the ship?
On price, usually not: across Hawaii ports the ship charges +30% on Carnival and +56% on NCL compared with independent tours of the same type, a typical per-person saving of $17 on Carnival and $80 on NCL.
Which Hawaii ports are tender ports?
Kona. Leave at least 90 minutes before departure to get back to the ship in a tender port.
Where do Hawaii excursions need extra time?
Honolulu, Maui (Kahului), Kona have popular tours with long transfers or ferries, so pick tours that finish well before all-aboard.
Other regions: Western Caribbean Bahamas Eastern Caribbean Southern Caribbean Central and South America Mexican Riviera Alaska Bermuda Canada and New England Europe